PCUSA Beliefs and How They Differ

1. What the PCUSA Is

The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), usually written PC(USA) and searched as PCUSA, is the largest Presbyterian denomination in the United States on the membership each Presbyterian body reports for itself, and it is the mainline body of American Presbyterianism. It came into being on 10 June 1983, when the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America and the Presbyterian Church in the United States reunited at a joint General Assembly in Atlanta, closing a division that had run along the lines of the Civil War since 1861. Its national offices are in Louisville, Kentucky, and its highest governing council is the General Assembly, which now meets every two years.

Comparative size follows the membership each Presbyterian body reports in its own annual statistics, published for the PCUSA by the Office of the General Assembly.

The name causes constant confusion, because a different denomination called the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. existed from 1789 until the 1958 merger that produced the United Presbyterian Church, and because the conservative Presbyterian Church in America carries an almost identical set of initials. When people search for what the PCUSA believes, they are usually asking about the mainline body described on this page. The conservative body has its own doctrine, discipline and history, set out in our guide to the Presbyterian Church in America.

Where It Sits Among the Churches

The PCUSA belongs to the Reformed family, the branch of the sixteenth-century Reformation shaped by John Calvin in Geneva and carried into Scotland by John Knox. It is a member of the World Communion of Reformed Churches, the National Council of Churches and the World Council of Churches, and it entered full communion with the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, the Reformed Church in America and the United Church of Christ through the 1997 Formula of Agreement. It is one of the churches that ecumenical observers group together as the American mainline, alongside the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, the Episcopal Church and the United Methodist Church.

2. What the PCUSA Believes

The PCUSA confesses the ancient Christian faith in Reformed terms: one God in three persons, Jesus Christ as fully God and fully human, crucified, risen and coming again, the Holy Spirit at work in the Church, the forgiveness of sins, and the life everlasting. A Brief Statement of Faith, written for the 1983 reunion and adopted into the Book of Confessions in 1991, is the shortest place to see the denomination stating its own convictions, and it opens by confessing that in life and in death we belong to God.

Scripture

The PCUSA teaches that Scripture is the unique and authoritative witness to Jesus Christ in the Church, and that the Word of God in the fullest sense is Jesus Christ himself. That framing comes from the Confession of 1967 and from the Theological Declaration of Barmen, and it distinguishes the denomination sharply from the inerrancy language used across most conservative Presbyterian bodies. The Confession of 1967 states that the Scriptures are nevertheless the words of men, conditioned by the language, thought forms and literary fashions of the places and times at which they were written, and that God speaks his word through them. Conservative Presbyterians read that formulation as a retreat from the doctrine of Scripture in the Westminster Confession, and PCUSA theologians read it as a christocentric account of biblical authority in the line of Karl Barth. For the Catholic doctrine of inspiration and the canon, see our guide to the Bible and how the Church reads it.

God, Grace and Election

Reformed theology teaches that salvation is entirely God's work, received by grace through faith, and that no human merit initiates it. The historic Presbyterian standards state this as a doctrine of election, and the Westminster Confession sets out decrees of predestination in its third chapter. The PCUSA holds Westminster among its confessions and does not use it as the sole measure of orthodoxy, and its own later confessions do not restate double predestination in that form. The northern Presbyterian church had already attached a declaratory statement to Westminster in 1903, softening chapter three and stating that the love of God is offered to all people. Our guides to Calvinism and the five points of Calvinism lay out the underlying system and the Catholic response to it.

Sin and Salvation

The PCUSA teaches original sin in the Reformed sense: human beings are born into a condition of estrangement from God from which they cannot free themselves, and reconciliation comes as God's initiative in Christ. The Confession of 1967 organizes the entire faith around the theme of reconciliation, taking 2 Corinthians 5:19 as its text, and it extends reconciliation from the individual to social divisions of race, nation, class and war. Justification is by faith alone, in the classic Reformation sense, with good works following as the fruit of faith rather than as its ground. Catholic teaching agrees that grace precedes and enables every good act, and it holds that justification involves a real interior renewal, a difference we work through in our guide to faith and works.

The Church and the Last Things

The PCUSA understands the Church as the body of Christ gathered by the Word and the Spirit, marked by right preaching, right administration of the sacraments and, in the Scots Confession, ecclesiastical discipline rightly ministered. It confesses the resurrection of the body and the life everlasting, and it says comparatively little about the state of the dead beyond that. A Brief Statement of Faith ends with the confession that with believers in every time and place Christians rejoice that nothing in life or in death can separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord, a direct echo of Romans 8:38 to 39. The denomination has no doctrine of purgatory, no invocation of the saints and no prayers for the dead, all of which the Reformed tradition rejected in the sixteenth century.

3. The Book of Confessions: Twelve Documents

The Book of Confessions is Part I of the PCUSA constitution, and it is the single feature that most distinguishes the denomination from every conservative Presbyterian body in the United States. It holds twelve documents written between the fourth century and 1986, gathered as a chorus of witnesses to what the Church has confessed in different centuries and different emergencies. Part II of the constitution is the Book of Order, which governs church government, worship and discipline.

What Is In It

The contents and dates above follow the PCUSA constitution as published by the Office of the General Assembly. The Confession of Belhar originated with the Dutch Reformed Mission Church in South Africa in 1986 and was received into the PCUSA Book of Confessions in 2016 after ratification by the presbyteries.

Why Twelve and Not One

The Book of Confessions was created in 1967 by the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America, which until then had held the Westminster standards as its single subordinate standard. The theological argument for the change was that no one confession is the faith itself, that each was written into a particular crisis, and that the Church confesses afresh in every age under the same Scripture. The practical effect was to place Westminster alongside Barmen and the Confession of 1967 as one voice among several, so that Westminster's assertions no longer function as the measure against which a minister is judged.

Barmen and Belhar carry particular weight in how the denomination understands itself. Barmen, drafted principally by Karl Barth in 1934, declared that Jesus Christ is the one Word of God whom the Church must hear and obey, and rejected the claim that the Church could take any other event, power or figure as a source of proclamation. Belhar, adopted by the Dutch Reformed Mission Church in South Africa, the body of the Dutch Reformed family to which mixed-race members were assigned under apartheid, declared that the separation of Christians by race is sin and that God is in a special way the God of the destitute and the wronged. Both confessions treat a political and social situation as a status confessionis, a matter on which the Church's confession is at stake, and that pattern shapes a great deal of PCUSA public witness.

What the Confessions Do Not Agree On

The twelve documents contradict one another at several points, and the denomination has never treated this as a defect. The Westminster Confession sets out a doctrine of the eternal decree that the Confession of 1967 does not carry forward. The Scots Confession and the Second Helvetic Confession describe the papacy in polemical terms the modern denomination does not use in its ecumenical work, and the northern Presbyterian church had already amended its own text of the Westminster Confession in 1903, removing from chapter 25 the identification of the pope as antichrist. A collection assembled from four centuries speaks in the accents of each of them, and reading it requires a principle for deciding which voice governs when the voices differ.

4. Ordination Vows and the Essential Tenets

PCUSA officers do not subscribe to the confessions clause by clause. At ordination, a minister, elder or deacon answers a set of constitutional questions, one of which asks whether the candidate sincerely receives and adopts the essential tenets of the Reformed faith as expressed in the confessions of this church as authentic and reliable expositions of what Scripture leads the Church to believe and do, and whether the candidate will be instructed and led by those confessions as the candidate leads the people of God.

The Phrase That Carries the Weight

Three features of that vow decide how PCUSA doctrine actually works. The candidate adopts the essential tenets, and the constitution nowhere lists what the essential tenets are. The confessions are received as authentic and reliable expositions of what Scripture leads the Church to believe, which subordinates them to Scripture and characterizes them as expositions. And the candidate promises to be instructed and led by them, a formula of guidance rather than of binding assent.

The consequence is that the body examining a candidate, the presbytery for ministers and the session for elders and deacons, determines in each case whether the candidate's convictions fall within the essential tenets. Two neighbouring presbyteries can reach different answers about the same theological position and both act constitutionally. The PCUSA describes this as the exercise of responsible judgment by the ordaining council, and its critics describe it as the absence of a doctrinal standard with teeth. Both descriptions are pointing at the same mechanism.

Attempts to Define the Tenets

The denomination has considered and declined to enumerate the essential tenets more than once. The Special Committee on Confessional Nature of the Church reported in 1986 that any attempt to reduce the confessions to a list of essentials would itself become a new and narrower creed. Conservative bodies within the denomination have published their own lists, notably the Presbyterian Coalition and later the Fellowship of Presbyterians, and those lists have never had constitutional force. The Kenyon case of 1975 established that some positions can be judged outside the essentials, and it did so on the question of women's ordination rather than on a classical doctrinal locus.

5. The Book of Order and How the PCUSA Is Governed

The PCUSA is governed by elected elders sitting in councils, which is what the word presbyterian means. The Book of Order, Part II of the constitution, contains the Foundations of Presbyterian Polity, the Form of Government, the Directory for Worship and the Rules of Discipline. No bishop holds personal jurisdiction anywhere in the system, and no congregation acts as a law to itself.

The Four Councils

Authority runs through four levels. The session governs the local congregation and consists of the pastor as moderator and the ruling elders elected by the congregation. The presbytery is the council of a region, made up of all its ministers and of ruling elders commissioned by the sessions, and it holds the decisive powers: it ordains and installs ministers, receives and dismisses congregations, and it is the body that most PCUSA disputes turn on. The synod covers a wider area and has been reduced in function over recent decades. The General Assembly is the national council, meeting biennially, with commissioners elected by the presbyteries and a moderator elected for the term.

How Doctrine and Polity Change

Constitutional change in the PCUSA runs through the presbyteries, and this is why the dates matter in every controversy. The General Assembly may propose an amendment to the Book of Order, and it takes effect only when a majority of presbyteries vote to approve it. Amendments to the Book of Confessions require a two-thirds majority of presbyteries plus the concurrence of a second General Assembly, a deliberately higher bar. The General Assembly may also issue an authoritative interpretation of the existing constitution, which takes effect without a presbytery vote, and the use of authoritative interpretations on contested questions has itself been contested inside the denomination.

Ordered Ministries

The PCUSA has three ordered ministries: ruling elder, deacon, and minister of Word and Sacrament, also called teaching elder. Ruling elders are ordained lay members elected by the congregation, and they are ordained for life and installed for terms. Deacons carry a ministry of compassion and service. Ministers of Word and Sacrament are members of a presbytery rather than of a congregation, which is why a pastoral dispute becomes a presbytery matter. Ordination is understood as the setting apart of a member of the Church for a function, and the Reformed tradition does not treat it as a sacrament that confers an indelible character. That difference is the root of the Catholic position described in section 13 and in our guide to the Catholic priesthood.

6. Worship and the Two Sacraments

PCUSA worship follows the Reformed pattern, ordered around the reading and preaching of Scripture, with prayer, psalms and hymns, a confession of sin and assurance of pardon, and the celebration of one of the two sacraments. The Directory for Worship in the Book of Order sets out principles and leaves wide latitude in form, so the range across congregations runs from Genevan psalmody and a full liturgical calendar to contemporary praise bands.

Baptism

The PCUSA baptizes infants and adults with water in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, and it teaches that baptism is the sign and seal of incorporation into Christ and into the covenant community. Baptism is administered once and is never repeated, and a person baptized in another Christian body is received without rebaptism. Reformed theology holds that the sacrament signifies and seals a grace that God gives, and it declines the Catholic formulation that the sacrament effects what it signifies by the working of the rite itself. Our guide to baptism sets out the Catholic doctrine and the reasons behind the difference.

The Lord's Supper

The PCUSA celebrates the Lord's Supper as a real communion with the risen Christ, following John Calvin, who taught that believers truly receive Christ in the Supper by the power of the Holy Spirit lifting them to where Christ is. Calvin's position sits between the Lutheran teaching of a bodily presence in the elements and the Zwinglian teaching of a memorial only, and PCUSA documents describe it as a real spiritual presence. The elements are not held to become the body and blood of Christ, and no reservation or adoration of the elements takes place. The table is open, and most PCUSA congregations invite all baptized Christians to receive, a practice that Catholic discipline does not reciprocate.

Frequency varies. The Directory for Worship encourages regular celebration, and many congregations communicate monthly or quarterly, while a growing number now celebrate weekly. The Catholic doctrine of the Eucharist, including transubstantiation and the sacrificial character of the Mass, is set out in our guide to the Eucharist.

7. Women's Ordination in the PCUSA

The PCUSA ordains women to all three of its ordered ministries, and it has done so through its predecessor bodies since well before the 1983 reunion. The northern church, then the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A., approved the ordination of women as ruling elders in 1930. The United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America approved the ordination of women as ministers of Word and Sacrament in 1956, and Margaret Towner was ordained that year. The southern Presbyterian Church in the United States approved women's ordination to the ministry in 1964. Women have served as moderators of the General Assembly, as presbytery executives and as seminary presidents.

The Kenyon Case

The 1975 Kenyon case turned the practice into a requirement. Walter Wynn Kenyon, a candidate for ordination who stated that he could not in conscience participate in ordaining a woman as an elder or minister, was approved by his presbytery and challenged on appeal. The General Assembly's Permanent Judicial Commission ruled that the candidate could not be ordained, holding that the equality of women in ordered ministry is a matter on which the constitution admits no scruple. That decision is the clearest instance of the PCUSA identifying a position as essential in practice, and it is regularly cited in arguments about what else might be treated the same way.

The Catholic Position, and Why It Differs

The Catholic Church holds that it has no authority to ordain women to the priesthood, a position John Paul II stated in the 1994 apostolic letter Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, grounding it in Christ's choice of the Twelve and the constant tradition of the Church rather than in any judgment about women's capacity. The difference between the two bodies here follows from the difference over what ordination is. If ordination sets a person apart for the functions of preaching and administering the sacraments, the question is one of gift and order. If ordination configures a man sacramentally to Christ as head of the Church in a priesthood that the Church received and cannot redefine, the question is one of what the Church has power to do. The two churches are answering different questions, and saying so is more useful than trading verses.

8. LGBT Ordination and Same-Sex Marriage

The PCUSA ordains partnered LGBT people to all its ordered ministries and permits its ministers to officiate same-sex marriages. Both changes came through the denomination's own constitutional machinery over roughly four decades, and the sequence matters, because each step relocated the decision rather than settling the underlying question at the national level.

The Sequence

In 1978 the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America adopted definitive guidance stating that self-affirming, practising homosexual persons should not be ordained, and the southern church adopted a similar position in 1979. The guidance was an interpretation rather than a constitutional provision, and it was contested repeatedly through the 1980s and 1990s.

In 1996 and 1997 the presbyteries ratified Amendment B, which wrote a standard into the Book of Order at G-6.0106b requiring officers to live either in fidelity within the covenant of marriage between a man and a woman or in chastity in singleness. That was the high-water mark of the restrictive position, and it lasted a little over a decade. In 2010 the General Assembly sent Amendment 10-A to the presbyteries, which ratified it in 2011. The amendment removed the fidelity and chastity clause and replaced it with a standard requiring officers to submit joyfully to the Lordship of Christ and to be guided by Scripture and the confessions, with the ordaining council responsible for determining the candidate's fitness. The effect was to move the question from a national rule to the session or presbytery in each case.

On marriage, the 221st General Assembly in 2014 issued an authoritative interpretation permitting ministers to officiate same-sex marriages in states where civil law allowed them, and it sent to the presbyteries an amendment to the Directory for Worship defining marriage as a commitment between two people, traditionally a man and a woman. The presbyteries ratified the amendment and it took effect on 21 June 2015. The same provisions state that no minister is required to officiate at any marriage and no session is required to allow its property to be used for one, a conscience protection that has held.

What the Denomination Says About Its Own Reasoning

PCUSA advocates of the change argued from the Confession of 1967 and Belhar that the Church confesses afresh under Scripture in each generation, that the biblical texts usually cited address exploitative practices in their own settings, and that the gifts evident in LGBT candidates for ministry were themselves testimony the Church should weigh. Opponents inside the denomination argued from the plain reading of Genesis 2, Romans 1, 1 Corinthians 6 and 1 Timothy 1, and from the unbroken teaching of the whole Christian tradition until the late twentieth century. Presenting only one of those cases would misdescribe what happened.

The Catholic Teaching

The Catholic Church teaches that marriage is a covenant between one man and one woman, ordered to the good of the spouses and to the procreation and education of children, and raised by Christ to the dignity of a sacrament between the baptized. It teaches that homosexual acts are contrary to the natural law, and in the same paragraphs it teaches that people with homosexual inclinations must be accepted with respect, compassion and sensitivity, and that every sign of unjust discrimination against them is to be avoided (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2357 to 2359). Both halves of that teaching are binding, and Catholics who cite the first while ignoring the second are misrepresenting their own Church. Our guide to marriage and the sacrament works through the Catholic doctrine in full.

9. Social Teaching and Public Witness

The PCUSA maintains an active national public witness, exercised through General Assembly resolutions, the Office of Public Witness in Washington, and the Presbyterian Mission Agency. Positions taken at a General Assembly speak for that Assembly and do not bind the conscience of members, a distinction the denomination states explicitly and that observers often miss.

Where the PCUSA Stands

The denomination has supported the legal availability of abortion since 1970, while its statements also describe abortion as a decision of grave moral weight and oppose its use as a means of birth control or sex selection. It has taken positions in favour of racial justice, refugee and immigrant protection, environmental care and the abolition of the death penalty, the last of these consistently since 1959. It has debated Israel and Palestine at length, and in 2014 the General Assembly voted narrowly to divest denominational funds from three companies over their operations in the Palestinian territories, a decision that drew substantial criticism and that the Assembly framed as a matter of corporate responsibility rather than a judgment on the state of Israel.

Where the Catholic Church Agrees and Where It Does Not

Catholic social teaching and PCUSA social witness overlap substantially on poverty, racism, migration, care for creation and opposition to capital punishment, which the Catechism, revised in 2018 at the direction of Pope Francis, now describes as inadmissible. They part decisively on abortion. Catholic teaching holds that human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception and that direct abortion is gravely contrary to the moral law (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2270 to 2271), which is a different position in kind from the PCUSA's. Our guides to abortion, capital punishment and Catholic social teaching set out the Catholic case on each.

10. The Splits: From Machen to ECO

Almost every conservative Presbyterian denomination in the United States exists because of a departure from a predecessor of the PCUSA. Reading the history of those departures explains both what the conservative bodies believe and why the mainline body looks the way it does now.

The Fundamentalist and Modernist Controversy

The first great conflict ran through the 1920s. The General Assembly had adopted deliverances in 1910, 1916 and 1923 naming five doctrines as essential and necessary, including the inerrancy of Scripture, the virgin birth, substitutionary atonement, the bodily resurrection and the miracles of Christ. In 1922 the Baptist preacher Harry Emerson Fosdick, then in a Presbyterian pulpit in New York, preached "Shall the Fundamentalists Win?", and the ensuing case brought the dispute to a head. In 1924 a document known as the Auburn Affirmation, signed by more than a thousand ministers, argued that the five points were theories rather than doctrines the constitution required, and that the General Assembly had no power to impose them without the presbyteries. The Affirmation prevailed in effect.

J. Gresham Machen, a New Testament scholar at Princeton Theological Seminary, argued in Christianity and Liberalism in 1923 that liberal theology was a different religion from Christianity rather than a variant of it. After Princeton was reorganized in 1929 he left to found Westminster Theological Seminary, and after the General Assembly ordered him to abandon an independent mission board he had established, he was suspended from the ministry and in 1936 formed what became the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

1973 and the PCA

The second great departure came from the southern church. Conservative congregations in the Presbyterian Church in the United States, objecting to the theological direction of the denomination, to the ordination of women approved in 1964 and to the coming reunion with the northern church, left in December 1973 to form what took the name Presbyterian Church in America. It holds the Westminster Confession and Catechisms as its sole subordinate standard and has grown through the decades in which the mainline body has contracted.

2012 and ECO

The third wave followed Amendment 10-A. Congregations and ministers who could not accept the 2011 change organized as the Fellowship of Presbyterians and in 2012 constituted a new denomination, ECO: A Covenant Order of Evangelical Presbyterians, which ordains women and holds a traditional position on sexuality. Others transferred to the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, formed in 1981. Departures were slowed by the PCUSA property trust clause, which holds that congregational property is held in trust for the denomination, and many exits were settled by negotiated payments through presbyteries. Congregational departures over doctrine are one strand in a wider pattern, which our guide to why people leave church examines from the personal side.

11. PCUSA and PCA Compared

PCUSA and PCA are separate denominations with different constitutions, different assemblies and different doctrinal structures, and the similarity of the initials causes real confusion. The table below is a summary; the conservative body is treated in full in our guide to the Presbyterian Church in America, and the broader tradition both belong to is covered in our guide to Presbyterianism.

Both columns follow each denomination's own published constitution and General Assembly records. Membership direction reflects the annual statistical reports each body publishes for itself, and the two bodies do not count membership on identical definitions.

12. Membership and the Shape of Decline

The PCUSA has lost more than half its membership since the 1983 reunion, on its own published figures. The Office of the General Assembly publishes comparative statistics every year covering membership, congregations, baptisms and finances, and those reports have shown net losses in every year of the denomination's existence. The reunited church reported roughly three million members at its formation, and its recent annual reports put membership at well under half that number.

Membership figures and the direction of change are drawn from the comparative statistics published annually by the Office of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), which is the denomination's own reporting. Exact totals move each year and definitions of active membership have changed over time, so the figures above are given as approximations rather than as precise counts.

What Is Driving It

Three causes are usually distinguished, and the evidence supports all three operating at once. Congregational departures after 2011 removed a defined block of members and congregations in a short period. Demographic decline is the larger and slower factor: mainline Protestant bodies have had below-replacement birth rates and an ageing membership for decades, and deaths exceed new members. General secularization is the third, and it affects every American religious body, including the Catholic Church, which has offset losses in the United States mainly through immigration. Our guide to whether Christianity is dying examines the data across bodies.

Reading the Numbers Honestly

Catholics gain nothing from treating the PCUSA's decline as an argument. The Catholic Church in the United States has lost a large share of those raised in it, its Mass attendance has fallen sharply over the same decades, and it has faced a scandal of its own making that our guide to church scandals does not soften. Decline is a shared condition of American Christianity, and the question of which body holds the fullness of the faith is settled on other grounds entirely.

13. What Catholics and the PCUSA Share and Divide On

Catholics and PCUSA Presbyterians share the Nicene faith, the Trinity, the incarnation, the atoning death and bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ, the authority of Scripture and the necessity of grace. The Second Vatican Council teaches that those who believe in Christ and have been properly baptized are in a certain, though imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church, and it calls them brothers and sisters in the Lord (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). The divisions are real, and they are mostly about the Church rather than about Christ.

Baptism, Recognized

The Catholic Church recognizes Presbyterian baptism as valid, provided it is performed with water and the Trinitarian formula, and a Presbyterian received into full communion is confirmed and admitted to the Eucharist without rebaptism. In 2010 the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops and four Reformed bodies, the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), the Reformed Church in America, the Christian Reformed Church in North America and the United Church of Christ, signed a Common Agreement on Mutual Recognition of Baptism, the fruit of the Catholic and Reformed dialogue in the United States.

Orders and Eucharist, Not Recognized

Catholic teaching does not recognize Presbyterian ordination as the sacrament of Holy Orders in apostolic succession, and it therefore does not recognize the Lord's Supper as celebrated in the PCUSA as the Eucharist in the full sense. Unitatis Redintegratio 22 states that the ecclesial communities separated from the Catholic Church have not preserved the proper reality of the eucharistic mystery in its fullness, above all because of the absence of the sacrament of Orders, and it says in the same passage that in the Lord's Supper they profess that the life of the Church is signified and they look for Christ's coming in glory. The Reformed tradition made a deliberate decision in the sixteenth century that ordination is a setting apart for office rather than a sacrament conferring a character, so the two churches disagree about what ordination is before they disagree about who holds it. Intercommunion is not permitted for that reason.

The Church, Tradition and the Saints

The PCUSA column summarizes the Book of Confessions and the Book of Order as the denomination publishes them. The Catholic column follows the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the documents of the Second Vatican Council. Individual PCUSA members and congregations vary considerably, and a confessional summary describes the constitution rather than every pew.

For the wider comparison across the Reformation divide, see our guide to Catholic and Protestant differences, and for the Catholic doctrine of Tradition that stands behind the first two rows, our guide to Sacred Tradition.

14. The Question a Book of Confessions Raises

A doctrinal standard made of twelve documents from four centuries has to answer one question that a single-confession church does not face: when the documents disagree, who decides which one governs. The PCUSA answers that the councils of the church decide, examining each case under Scripture and instructed by the confessions as a whole. That answer is coherent, it has a serious theological rationale in the Reformed conviction that the Church confesses afresh in every age, and it is the honest description of how the denomination works.

The Catholic observation is about where it leads. If the standard is a collection, the criterion is undefined, and the judgment belongs to whichever assembly is sitting, then the content of the faith tracks the composition of the assemblies. Amendment B in 1997 and Amendment 10-A in 2011 were produced by the same constitutional machinery, fourteen years apart, and reached opposite conclusions. Neither was irregular. The machinery did what it is built to do.

What the Catholic Church Claims Instead

The Catholic Church claims that Christ gave the apostles and their successors a teaching office that speaks with his authority, that this office is held by the bishops in communion with the Bishop of Rome, and that the Holy Spirit preserves it from error when it definitively proposes a doctrine of faith or morals. The claim rests on Matthew 16:18 to 19, on John 21:15 to 17, on the practice of the council in Acts 15, and on the way the early Church actually settled disputes about the divinity of Christ. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that the task of interpreting the Word of God authentically has been entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church, which serves the Word of God rather than standing above it (CCC 85 to 86).

Stating the Objection Fairly

A Presbyterian has a serious answer to this, and it deserves stating. Reformed theology holds that a magisterium claiming to be preserved from error is itself a human institution making a claim Scripture does not grant, that the historical record of the papacy makes the claim hard to credit, and that placing final interpretive authority in a body that also defines its own competence removes the possibility of correction under the Word of God. Barmen was written precisely against a church that had let something other than Christ speak with authority. Those objections are not evasions, and a Catholic who has not read them has not engaged the question.

The Catholic reply is that the magisterium is bound by Scripture and Tradition and cannot invent doctrine, that its definitions have consistently narrowed rather than expanded what may be believed, and that the alternative has to be tested by what it produces. A church that relocates the criterion to the interpreting assembly has no mechanism by which a later assembly can be told it was wrong, because the earlier one held the same authority. That is the structural point this page exists to make, and it is a claim about mechanisms rather than about the sincerity of anyone inside the PCUSA.

If You Are Reading This While Deciding Something

People search for what the PCUSA believes for three reasons, and each deserves a different word. Some are choosing a church and want the facts, and the facts are in sections 2 through 8 above. Some are members watching their congregation change and wondering what the constitution actually says, and the answer is in sections 3 and 4. Some are Catholics with Presbyterian family who want to talk about it without giving offence, and the way to do that is to learn the Reformed position from Reformed sources, state it accurately, and then say what you hold and why. Christ prayed that his followers would be one (John 17:21). That prayer is not answered by pretending the differences are small.

15. Related Topics