What Is a Pilgrimage in Catholicism

1. What a Pilgrimage Is

A pilgrimage is a journey made to a holy place as an act of prayer and penance. The place is holy because something of God's work is remembered there: the site of an event in salvation history, the tomb or relics of a saint, an image or shrine around which the Church has gathered to pray for generations. The journey itself is part of the prayer, which is why pilgrims have always accepted a measure of difficulty on the way rather than removing it.

The English word carries its own definition. Latin peregrinus means a foreigner, someone away from home and without the protection of citizenship, and peregrinatio is the condition of being abroad. A pilgrim is a person who has deliberately made themselves a stranger for a time. Scripture uses that image for the whole Christian life. Jacob calls his years "the days of my pilgrimage" (Genesis 47:9), Hebrews describes the patriarchs as strangers and exiles on the earth (Hebrews 11:13), and 1 Peter 2:11 addresses Christians as sojourners and exiles. A pilgrimage to a particular place is a short, physical rehearsal of that lifelong condition.

Three things a pilgrimage always has

• A destination that is holy for a reason you can name. Somewhere the Church has recognised, with a story attached. Vagueness about why the place matters is the first sign that a trip has stopped being a pilgrimage.
• An intention. Pilgrims go for something: a conversion, a healing, a decision, a bereavement, a thanksgiving, the salvation of a person they love. The intention is what turns travel into petition.
• Prayer and penance on the way. Fasting, the rosary, silence, walking, the sacrament of confession before departure or on arrival. Ancient pilgrims went barefoot on the last stretch; modern ones can at least go quietly.

2. The Pilgrim Feasts of Israel

Pilgrimage begins in the Law of Moses as a command. Israel was to appear before the Lord three times a year at the place he would choose, and the three occasions became the pilgrim feasts: Unleavened Bread with Passover in the spring, Weeks (Pentecost) seven weeks later, and Booths (Tabernacles) in the autumn.

The same three feasts are commanded in Exodus 23:14-17 and set out with their offerings in Leviticus 23. Before the Temple was built, the destination moved with the sanctuary: Elkanah and Hannah went up year by year to Shiloh, and it was there that Hannah prayed for a son (1 Samuel 1:3-11). Once Solomon's Temple stood in Jerusalem, the city became the fixed point toward which the whole nation turned three times a year.

The Songs of Ascents

Psalms 120 to 134 carry the heading "A Song of Ascents", and the tradition understands them as the songs of pilgrims climbing the road up to Jerusalem. They are short, portable and shaped for walking. They begin in distance and trouble, "I call on the Lord in my distress" (Psalm 120:1), and end at the sanctuary at night, "Praise the Lord, all you servants of the Lord who minister by night in the house of the Lord" (Psalm 134:1). Between them sits the pilgrim's opening line, which the Church still sings on the way into a shrine.

Two features of the Israelite pattern carry straight into Christian practice. The pilgrim goes up for a feast, at a time the calendar sets rather than a time of personal convenience. And the pilgrim does not arrive empty-handed. An offering, then an animal or a portion of the harvest, now more often alms, a candle, or the intentions of other people carried to the shrine, belongs to the shape of the act.

Longing when the journey was impossible

Israel also produced the literature of the pilgrim who cannot go. Psalm 42 is the song of a man far from the sanctuary remembering "how I used to go to the house of God under the protection of the Mighty One with shouts of joy and praise among the festive throng" (Psalm 42:4). Psalm 84 blesses "those whose hearts are set on pilgrimage" (Psalm 84:5). That strand matters, because most Christians in most centuries have been unable to travel far. The desire counts, and the Church has always said so.

3. Jerusalem, Luke 2 and the Emmaus Road

Jesus was raised in a pilgrim household. Luke records the practice plainly and then builds one of his most famous scenes on it.

The finding of Jesus in the Temple (Luke 2:41-52) happens because a pilgrim caravan travelled together, and a child could be assumed to be somewhere in the company for a day's journey before anyone counted. Mary and Joseph search for three days and find him among the teachers. The episode is the fifth joyful mystery of the rosary, and it fixes pilgrimage inside the ordinary religious life of the Holy Family. They went every year, on foot, with relatives and neighbours, because the Law said to go.

John's Gospel structures its whole account around the feasts that brought Jesus up to Jerusalem, and the final journey of Luke's Gospel is a pilgrimage that ends at the cross: "As the time approached for him to be taken up to heaven, Jesus resolutely set out for Jerusalem" (Luke 9:51). Pilgrimage in the Gospels is a road toward a sacrifice.

The Emmaus road

The pattern that every later pilgrimage imitates is set on Easter afternoon. Two disciples walk from Jerusalem to a village about seven miles away, talking about everything that had happened, and the risen Christ joins them on the road without being recognised (Luke 24:13-16). He walks with them, opens the Scriptures to them, and is finally known in the breaking of the bread.

Three things in that account describe what a pilgrimage is for. Christ is present on the road before he is recognised at the destination. Scripture is what makes the road intelligible, and their hearts burn while he explains it (Luke 24:32). And the recognition happens in the Eucharist, which is why a pilgrimage that skips Mass has skipped the point. The two disciples then walk the whole seven miles back to Jerusalem that same night to tell the others, which is the last element: a pilgrimage ends at home, with something to report.

4. The First Christian Pilgrims

Christian pilgrimage as a documented, organised practice begins in the fourth century, once the persecutions ended and travel to Palestine became safe. Local devotion at the tombs of martyrs is older, and the archaeology of second and third century Rome shows Christians visiting and marking those graves. What the fourth century added was distance.

The Bordeaux Pilgrim, 333

The Itinerarium Burdigalense, which scholars generally identify as the earliest surviving Christian travel account, was written by an anonymous traveller who went from Bordeaux in Gaul to Jerusalem and back in 333. Much of it is a bare list of staging posts and distances, the ancient equivalent of a road book, and then it slows down in Palestine to name the places: the pool of Siloam, the Mount of Olives, Bethlehem, the sites the pilgrim was shown. The document proves that ordinary Christians were making the journey within a generation of Constantine's legalisation of the faith.

Helena and the Constantinian churches

Around 326 to 328 the empress Helena, mother of Constantine, travelled to Palestine. Eusebius of Caesarea, writing in the Life of Constantine within living memory of the journey, credits her with the churches raised at Bethlehem over the cave of the Nativity and on the Mount of Olives. Constantine's builders also cleared the site of Golgotha and the tomb and raised the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, dedicated in 335. The tradition that Helena herself discovered the True Cross appears in sources from later in the same century, among them the funeral oration Ambrose of Milan preached for the emperor Theodosius in 395. Her feast is kept on 18 August in the Roman calendar, and the story of her journey is told on our page for St Helena.

Egeria

The most vivid early witness is a woman. Egeria, probably from the far west of the empire and probably a consecrated woman writing home to a community of sisters, travelled through Egypt, Sinai, Palestine, Syria and Asia Minor in the early 380s and wrote a long letter about it. Her text survives incomplete in a single manuscript, identified in 1884 by Gian Francesco Gamurrini in a library at Arezzo.

Egeria is precious for two reasons. She describes the fourth-century liturgy of Jerusalem in detail no other source matches, including the Palm Sunday procession down the Mount of Olives with branches, the all-night vigils, and the veneration of the wood of the cross on Good Friday with a deacon guarding the relic. Much of the Church's Holy Week is recognisable in her account. And she describes the emotional shape of pilgrimage without embarrassment: she climbs Sinai, has the Scripture passage read aloud at the place it happened, prays, and moves on. Reading the text at the site is her constant practice, and it is still the best single piece of advice a pilgrim can be given.

Not everyone approved. Gregory of Nyssa wrote a letter arguing that changing your address does not bring you closer to God and that the Holy Spirit is not more abundant in Jerusalem than in Cappadocia. Jerome, who settled in Bethlehem, conceded the principle and kept the practice, observing that the holy places help the mind but that heaven is as open from Britain as from Jerusalem. The Church has held both truths ever since: God is everywhere, and human beings are bodies, and bodies are helped by places.

5. The Medieval Roads

By the central Middle Ages three destinations stood above the rest, and medieval writers grouped pilgrims by them. Those who went to Jerusalem were palmieri, palmers, for the palm branch they brought back. Those who went to Rome were romei. Those who went to Santiago de Compostela were named for the scallop shell they wore.

Jerusalem

Jerusalem was the first and hardest. Pilgrim traffic continued under Muslim rule after 638, with periods of protection and periods of danger, and the difficulty of the journey was part of the argument preachers used when the crusading movement began at the end of the eleventh century. That history is a subject of its own, and we treat it in the guide to the Crusades. Franciscans have been present at the Latin holy places since the thirteenth century, and Clement VI confirmed their Custody of the Holy Land in 1342. They still care for the sites and receive pilgrims.

Rome

Rome held the tombs of Peter and Paul, and the phrase ad limina apostolorum, to the thresholds of the apostles, described the visit. Pilgrims came for the relics, for the great basilicas, and for the sight of the Veronica cloth, which drew crowds through the later Middle Ages. The northern route acquired a name and a shape: the Via Francigena, the road of the Franks, whose stages are recorded in the itinerary kept by Sigeric, Archbishop of Canterbury, on his return from Rome around 990.

Santiago de Compostela

The shrine of the apostle James in Galicia grew from the ninth century and became the great walking pilgrimage of the West. The Codex Calixtinus, compiled in the twelfth century, contains in its fifth book a guide for pilgrims, traditionally attributed to a French cleric named Aymeric Picaud, describing the road, its rivers, its hospitality and its hazards. Confraternities and hospices grew up along the route to shelter travellers, and the scallop shell became the badge that identified a pilgrim and secured him a night's lodging. The Camino is walked today by pilgrims from across the world, and the Pilgrim's Office in Santiago publishes an annual count of the certificates it issues to those who complete it.

Figures for completed pilgrimages to Santiago are published by the Oficina de Acogida al Peregrino, the Pilgrim's Office of the Archdiocese of Santiago de Compostela, which issues the Compostela certificate. This page cites no figure of its own.

The rest of the map

Below the great three sat hundreds of regional shrines that mattered enormously to the people who lived near them: Canterbury after the murder of Thomas Becket in his own cathedral on 29 December 1170 and his canonisation in 1173, Mont Saint-Michel on its tidal rock, Assisi after Francis, Walsingham in Norfolk, Cologne for the shrine of the Magi, Loreto for the Holy House. Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, written in the 1380s and 1390s, gives an unsparing portrait of what a pilgrim company sounded like. Chaucer's pilgrims squabble, boast, tell filthy stories and travel for mixed motives. Pilgrimage has always been made by ordinary people.

6. The Holy Year and the Road to Rome

The Jubilee is the Church's own institution of pilgrimage, and it began in 1300 when Boniface VIII proclaimed a year of remission for those who came to Rome and visited the basilicas of the apostles. The idea was drawn from the jubilee year of Leviticus 25, with its release of debts and return of land, and it caught on immediately. The interval was shortened over the following centuries, from a hundred years to fifty and then to the twenty-five year cycle the Church keeps now, so that most people would see one in a lifetime.

Two elements of the Holy Year are worth knowing because they shape how Catholics talk about pilgrimage generally. The first is the Holy Door. Each of the papal basilicas in Rome has a door opened only in a Jubilee, and passing through it is the ritual centre of the pilgrimage, a physical enactment of Christ's words "I am the gate; whoever enters through me will be saved" (John 10:9). The second is that dioceses designate their own churches for the Holy Year, so that a pilgrim who cannot travel to Rome can make the Jubilee pilgrimage locally. The Church has been careful about this for centuries. Distance is not the measure.

The most recent Ordinary Jubilee opened on 24 December 2024 and closed on 6 January 2026, under the theme "Pilgrims of Hope". Our guide to the Jubilee of 2025 covers the Holy Year itself, what it asked of pilgrims, and what carries on after it. The next ordinary Jubilee falls in 2050.

7. The Reformation Objection and the Catholic Answer

The late medieval pilgrimage system attracted serious criticism from inside the Church before the Reformation broke. The trade in relics, the selling of badges, the pilgrim who travelled to escape his obligations at home, and the confusion of the indulgence with the purchase of forgiveness were all attacked by Catholic writers. Erasmus satirised shrine devotion sharply in his colloquy on pilgrimage, published in the 1520s, while remaining in the Church.

The Protestant position, stated fairly

Martin Luther rejected pilgrimage in his 1520 Address to the Christian Nobility of the German Nation, arguing that it drew people away from their duties to family and neighbour, encouraged the idea that God's grace could be earned by works and travel, and served the financial interests of shrines. Reformed teaching went further, treating veneration at relics and images as a breach of the first commandment. Most magisterial Protestant churches accordingly abolished shrine pilgrimage, and the shrine at Canterbury was destroyed in 1538 under Henry VIII.

The metaphor survived intact in Protestant devotion. John Bunyan's The Pilgrim's Progress, published in 1678, casts the whole Christian life as a journey, and it contains no shrine at all. In the twentieth century some Anglican communities restored pilgrimage in practice, notably at Walsingham, which today has both an Anglican and a Catholic shrine.

The Eastern Orthodox churches never stopped. Pilgrimage to Jerusalem, to Mount Athos and to the great monastic centres has continued unbroken among them. The Oriental Orthodox churches, which are a distinct communion of their own, keep their own pilgrimages, and the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church gathers at the rock-hewn churches of Lalibela for Genna, the Ethiopian Christmas. Islam and Judaism keep their own obligations of pilgrimage, and the Catholic Church makes no claim on those.

What Trent said

The Council of Trent answered in its final session in 1563, in the decree on the invocation and veneration of saints, relics and sacred images. The council affirmed that the bodies of the martyrs and saints are to be venerated, that God grants benefits through them, and in the same breath ordered bishops to root out the abuses: superstition, financial exploitation, disorder and revelry at shrines, and the display of dubious relics. The Catholic answer to the Reformation critique was to keep the practice and discipline it.

That is still the Church's posture. Pilgrimage is defended and supervised. The question of what human works can and cannot do is treated at length in our guide to faith and works, and the distinction matters here: a pilgrimage is an expression of faith and an act of penance offered by someone already living in grace, and no journey purchases anything from God.

8. What the Church Teaches a Pilgrimage Is

Catholic teaching places pilgrimage among the forms of popular piety, alongside processions, the stations of the cross, the veneration of relics and the rosary. The Catechism of the Catholic Church lists it there in paragraph 1674 and returns to it in the section on prayer.

Three things follow from that sentence, and they settle most of the questions people bring to the subject.

A pilgrimage is a devotion rather than a sacrament

The seven sacraments are the ordinary channels through which Christ gives grace, and pilgrimage is none of them. A pilgrimage is an act of devotion that disposes a person toward the sacraments, which is why Catholic shrines are organised around confessionals and altars. The Church has never taught that a Catholic must make a pilgrimage, and it has never taught that a Catholic who never leaves the parish is at any disadvantage before God. Everything necessary for salvation is available in the nearest church.

A pilgrimage is a sign of something true about the whole Church

The Second Vatican Council's constitution Lumen Gentium devotes a chapter to the pilgrim character of the Church, the Church on the way, not yet arrived, journeying between Christ's ascension and his return. A physical pilgrimage acts that out. The road, the fatigue, the arrival: they are a compressed model of a Christian life. That is why the Catechism says pilgrimages evoke the earthly journey toward heaven.

Shrines are recognised, and popular piety is guided

Canon law defines a shrine as a church or other sacred place to which the faithful make pilgrimage for a special reason of piety, with the approval of the local bishop (canon 1230 of the 1983 Code). The Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy, issued by the Congregation for Divine Worship in 2001, devotes a chapter to shrines and pilgrimages and sets out what the Church expects of them: that the liturgy be celebrated well, that the sacrament of penance be genuinely available, that Scripture be preached, that hospitality be offered to the poor, and that commerce be kept in its place. The recurring instruction across all these documents is the same. Popular piety is a real treasure of the faithful, and it needs the liturgy at its centre to stay healthy.

9. Indulgences, Stated Exactly

Some pilgrimages carry an indulgence, and the subject causes more confusion than any other part of the practice. The confusion is worth clearing carefully, because the Church's actual teaching is narrower and more modest than either its defenders or its critics usually make it sound.

An indulgence is the remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states it in paragraphs 1471 to 1479, drawing on Paul VI's apostolic constitution Indulgentiarum Doctrina of 1 January 1967. Two words in that definition carry the whole weight.

"Already been forgiven"

An indulgence does not forgive sin. Forgiveness of sin comes through the sacrament of penance, where a priest absolves in the person of Christ, and for the unbaptised through baptism. An indulgence presupposes that the guilt of sin is already dealt with in confession. Anyone who describes an indulgence as buying or earning forgiveness has described something the Catholic Church does not teach and formally condemned the sale of. Our guide to the sacrament of confession covers the forgiveness of sin itself.

"Temporal punishment"

Catholic teaching distinguishes the eternal consequence of grave sin, which is separation from God and is remitted with the guilt in absolution, from the temporal consequences: the disordered attachments, the habits, the damage left in the soul and in other people after the sin is forgiven. Purification of those remains is what an indulgence addresses, drawing on what the tradition calls the treasury of the Church, the infinite merits of Christ and the merits of the saints. The related doctrine of purification after death is treated in our guide to purgatory.

The conditions the Church actually attaches

For a plenary indulgence, the Church requires the prescribed work itself, which for a pilgrimage means the specific visit or act the grant names, and four conditions:

1. Sacramental confession.
2. Eucharistic Communion.
3. Prayer for the intentions of the Holy Father.
4. Freedom from all attachment to sin, including venial sin.

The fourth is the one that gets skipped in summaries and is the most demanding of the four. Where that complete detachment is absent, the Church's own norms say the indulgence obtained is partial rather than plenary. A plenary indulgence can be gained once a day, and it can be applied to oneself or offered for someone who has died, and it cannot be applied to another living person. The conditions are set out in the Enchiridion Indulgentiarum, the Manual of Indulgences published by the Apostolic Penitentiary.

The definition and conditions summarised here are from the Catechism of the Catholic Church 1471 to 1479, Paul VI's apostolic constitution Indulgentiarum Doctrina (1967), and the norms in the Enchiridion Indulgentiarum issued by the Apostolic Penitentiary. Particular grants attached to particular shrines are made by the competent authority and change over time. Check with the shrine or the diocese rather than with a website.

10. Pilgrimage and Tourism

Pilgrims and tourists arrive at the same places, walk the same floors and photograph the same facades. The difference lies in the purpose the traveller carries, and it shows up in the itinerary within about an hour of arrival.

The two overlap constantly, and pretending otherwise helps nobody. Pilgrims eat well, admire the architecture, buy things in the shop and enjoy the company. The Directory on Popular Piety treats the overlap realistically, noting that many people arrive at shrines as tourists and leave as something else, and it asks shrine staff to receive everyone rather than sorting them at the door. The medieval pilgrim on the Camino was also seeing the world, and everyone knew it.

The practical test is what happens when the two purposes conflict. A shrine has a confession queue and the coach leaves in forty minutes. A pilgrim joins the queue. That single decision, repeated a few times across a trip, is the whole difference.

The organised pilgrimage

Many Catholics who travel to a distant shrine go with a group led by a priest, and there are good reasons for that. Mass is guaranteed, confession is available in your own language, someone who knows the site explains what you are looking at, and the group prays the rosary and the liturgy of the hours together on the way. The risk of the organised form is a schedule so full that the site becomes a series of stops. Groups that build in silence do better than groups that do not.

11. What Church Approval of a Shrine Means

Many well-known Catholic shrines grew up around a reported apparition, and pilgrims constantly ask which of them the Church has "approved". The answer changed shape in 2024, and getting the language right matters.

On 17 May 2024 the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith published new Norms for Proceeding in the Discernment of Alleged Supernatural Phenomena. Under these norms the Church ordinarily does not declare that an apparition is supernatural. The competent authority, normally the diocesan bishop acting with the Dicastery, reaches one of six conclusions:

• Nihil obstat. Nothing stands in the way. Public devotion is permitted, and no declaration of supernatural origin is made.
• Prae oculis habeatur. There are positive signs, together with concerns that require watchfulness and clarification.
• Curatur. There are significant problems, and because devotion is already widespread it is not prohibited, and it is to be discouraged.
• Sub mandato. A person or group is misusing the phenomenon, and the competent authority takes direct charge of the site rather than acting against the phenomenon itself.
• Prohibetur et obstruitur. The negative elements are serious, and public devotion is prohibited.
• Declaratio de non supernaturalitate. A declaration that the phenomenon is not supernatural.

The six conclusions above are those set out in the Norms for Proceeding in the Discernment of Alleged Supernatural Phenomena, published by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith on 17 May 2024. The Latin terms are the Dicastery's own.

Medjugorje in Bosnia and Herzegovina is the case most people ask about. On 19 September 2024 the Dicastery issued a note titled The Queen of Peace granting a nihil obstat. That permits public devotion at Medjugorje and makes no declaration that the apparitions are supernatural. Describing Medjugorje as "approved" states more than the Church has said. Describing it as "rejected" or as "still under study" states something the Church has not said either.

The older shrines were judged under a different framework, and the acts behind them differ from one another. Lourdes and Fatima rest on decisions of their local bishops in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries respectively. Guadalupe rests on centuries of immemorial devotion and a series of papal acts rather than on any apparition decree, which is why claims about a single deciding document there are usually wrong. Knock, La Salette, Pontmain, Beauraing, Banneux, Laus, Champion in Wisconsin, Kibeho in Rwanda and Akita in Japan each have their own documentary history. Our pages on Fatima and Guadalupe go into those two in detail. Garabandal in Spain is sometimes described as unresolved, and the Diocese of Santander investigated it from the 1960s and issued negative determinations.

12. How to Prepare

Preparation is where a pilgrimage is largely won or lost. The interior preparation carries most of the weight, and the logistics carry less of it than people expect.

Name the intention, and write it down

Go for something. A conversion in the family, a marriage under strain, a decision about work or vocation, a diagnosis, a grief, gratitude for something already given. Write one sentence on a piece of paper and carry it. Vague pilgrimages produce vague experiences, and the discipline of naming a single intention gives the whole journey a spine.

Learn the place before you see it

Egeria's habit is the best method available: read the relevant text at the relevant place. Find out what happened there, when, to whom, and what the Church concluded about it. Know the feast day of the shrine, because the shrine's own year turns on it and the liturgy is fullest then. Arriving informed means the first hour is prayer rather than orientation.

Go to confession before you leave

Confession before departure is the traditional beginning of a pilgrimage, and it puts the journey on the right footing. Confession is also available at almost every significant shrine, often in several languages, and many pilgrims go again on arrival. Nothing about a shrine works better on a soul carrying unconfessed grave sin.

Agree a rule of prayer for the road

Something simple and repeatable, kept whether the day goes well or badly. A decade of the rosary at each stop, morning prayer from the liturgy of the hours, the Angelus at noon, one psalm of ascent each day. Our guide to Christian prayer covers the forms. A rule you can keep while tired is worth more than an ambitious one abandoned on day two.

The practical list

• Carry your own bag. The weight is part of it, and a pack you cannot lift ruins a walking pilgrimage on the first afternoon.
• Break in the shoes. Blisters end walking pilgrimages, and new boots cause them.
• Leave slack in the schedule. Days without gaps have no room for the thing you actually came for.
• Take other people's intentions. Ask your parish, your family and your colleagues what they want prayed for. Carry the list.
• Bring alms. The oldest instruction on pilgrimage is that nobody appears before the Lord empty-handed (Deuteronomy 16:16).
• Plan the return. Decide in advance what you will do in the first week home, because that is when a pilgrimage is kept or lost.
• Fast in some small way. Alcohol, meat, a meal, the phone. Choose one thing and keep it, and tell nobody.

If you cannot travel

Age, money, illness and duty keep many people from distant shrines, and the Church has never treated that as a loss. A local pilgrimage to a cathedral or a nearby shrine church, made on foot with the same intention and the same prayers, is a pilgrimage. So is a day given to the stations of the cross in your own parish. Psalm 84:5 blesses "those whose hearts are set on pilgrimage", and it says nothing about the mileage.

13. What a Pilgrim Does on Arrival

Arrival has an old shape, and it holds up well.

Walk the last stretch

Where the site allows it, get out of the vehicle and cover the final distance on foot, in silence. Medieval pilgrims did the last miles barefoot; the modern equivalent is simply refusing to be delivered to the door. The body needs to understand that it has arrived somewhere.

Go to the church first

Before the shop, the café or the viewing platform, go into the church or the shrine itself and kneel. Say the intention you wrote down. Then say nothing for a while. Everything else in the visit goes better once this is done.

Confession and Mass

These are the centre of the visit, and a pilgrimage that misses them has missed the reason the shrine exists. Find the confession times, and go. Assist at Mass at the shrine, and if you can, at the principal Mass rather than a convenient early one. The Emmaus pattern holds: the recognition happens in the breaking of the bread. Our guide to the Mass covers what is happening in it.

Venerate what is there to venerate

Kiss the relic, touch the stone, light the candle, walk the holy stairs, pass through the door. Catholic devotion is physical because the Incarnation is physical, and God has chosen to work through matter. Do these things without embarrassment and without superstition. A candle is a prayer left burning after you leave, and it does nothing on its own.

Stay longer than you planned

A common regret is a schedule that moved the group along just as something began. If there is one hour to spare in the whole trip, spend it sitting still in the shrine. Shrines reward duration.

Pray for the people who sent you

Take out the list. Name every person on it, out loud if you can do so without disturbing anyone. This is the oldest service a pilgrim performs for a community that stayed home, and it is the reason communities used to send them.

Then go home and keep something

The two disciples walked seven miles back to Jerusalem the same night (Luke 24:33). A pilgrimage finishes in ordinary life. Choose one thing to keep: a weekly holy hour, monthly confession, a decade of the rosary each day, one specific reconciliation you have been avoiding. One kept resolution is the fruit of a pilgrimage. Good feelings on the road fade by the second week home.

14. Honest Objections

"God is everywhere, so why travel?"

God is everywhere, and Gregory of Nyssa made this argument in the fourth century against pilgrimage to Jerusalem. The Catholic answer accepts the premise and denies the conclusion. Human beings are embodied, and memory attaches to places, which is why we bury the dead in marked graves and return to them. God became flesh at a particular address in a particular decade, and the Church has never treated location as irrelevant to a religion founded on the Incarnation. Pilgrimage helps because we are bodies, and God knows we are bodies.

"Is this just a Catholic holiday with prayers attached?"

Sometimes it is, and the Church has been complaining about that since Chaucer. The corrective is structural rather than attitudinal: keep Mass and confession in the schedule, keep the intention in your pocket, keep some real penance in the day. A pilgrimage with those three things holds its shape even when the traveller is distracted, tired and enjoying the food.

"Are shrines just after money?"

Shrines cost money to run, they employ people, and they take offerings, and the Church has legislated repeatedly against exploitation at them, from the Council of Trent in 1563 to the Directory on Popular Piety in 2001. Where you find high-pressure selling, ignore it and go to the sacraments. Where you find hospitality for the poor and sick, which the great shrines are known for, support it.

"Do I have to believe in the apparition?"

No. The Church has never required belief in any private revelation. Even at shrines with the fullest recognition, a Catholic is free to be unconvinced by the apparition and still pray there. What Catholics believe is the public revelation that closed with the apostles, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church 67 says private revelations do not belong to the deposit of faith and do not improve on Christ's definitive revelation.

"Isn't this earning grace by works?"

The Council of Trent condemned the idea that a person can merit initial justification, and Catholic teaching holds that grace comes first in every case. A pilgrimage is the response of someone already in grace, an act of love and penance offered back. Nobody has ever been saved by walking somewhere. People are saved by Christ, and some of them met him more clearly because they walked.

15. Related Topics